Vietnamese crab exporter

Exclusive: Intel oversights, anger against cow vigilante fueled violence in Haryana's Nuh

An investigation by India Today into the clashes in Haryana's Nuh uncovered intelligence oversights and anger against Monu Manesar, a cow vigilante, as key factors contributing to the violence.

Advertisement
haryana nuh violence probe
Kishan Kumar, the SHO of Nuh police station and District Inspector Vishvajeet spoke on what fueled the violence. (India Today photo)

Four people were killed in Haryana's Nuh on Monday after clashes erupted between two groups during a procession by the Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP). The violence has now spread to Gurugram and incidents of vandalism took place on Tuesday too. An investigation by India Today into the violence in Nuh has uncovered intelligence oversights and inadequacy in police deployment as key factors contributing to the violence.

advertisement

INTEL IGNORED

Nuh District Inspector (CID) Vishvajeet, who is responsible for gathering intel across the district, said that his department had issued formal warnings to local authorities about potential trouble during the Vishwa Hindu Parishad’s 130-km Braj Mandal Yatra passing through Muslim-dominated areas.

"Yes, we were specific (in mentioning) that these people would encounter them (the locals) somewhere during the yatra...that they (the yatra) would pass through, shouting slogans and waving swords,” Vishvajeet told India Today’s Special Investigation Team. “We did share everything with the government almost a week or ten days ago," he added. 

ANGER OVER COW VIGILANTE

Monu Manesar, a notorious cow vigilante associated with the Bajrang Dal, had earlier issued video messages about him participating in the yatra. However, he did not participate on the VHP's advice as the group feared that his presence would create tension. But a rumour about his presence acted as a trigger for the violence.

"Someone spread the rumour about him (Monu Manesar) coming. They (the locals) prepared to stop the yatra from proceeding. They wanted to block its route," Vishvajeet said. "Senior officials thought they could manage the situation and disperse the crowds (in case of trouble). They took it normally. They thought they could convince the locals that Monu Manesar didn’t show up," he told India Today. 

According to Vishvajeet, the locals gathered swiftly in villages after the rumours of Monu Manesar attending the yatra spread. They left for the yatra route on their bikes, he said.

“They were all young men aged between 17-22. None mature among them,” Vishvajeet added.

CRACKDOWN ON CYBER CRIME

Rioters also rammed a bus into a cyber police station in Nuh, now an infamous hub of cyber crime in the country. According to Vishvajeet, the measures by the police station had left villagers in the district angry.

"The crackdown on cyber crime has caused a lot of problems for them. Additionally, there are restrictions on cow slaughter. They (the locals) wondered why police had been raiding their homes," Vishvajeet said.

NO INTEL COORDINATION

Kishan Kumar, the Station House Officer (SHO) of the police station under whose jurisdiction the violence unfolded, claimed he did not receive intel from his superiors about potential trouble during the yatra. "I didn’t receive anything. Nothing of the sort, at least at my level. Had we known beforehand about this situation, we could have acted. The yatra wasn’t an emergency exercise (which had to take place)," Kumar said.

INADEQUATE FORCE

advertisement

In a separate conversation with India Today’s investigative team, the SHO explained how the available force was spread too thin across the route of the yatra.

"The available force was all on duty. It was spread across the entire route. And the route got expanded too. There were no extra personnel. The (picket) points increased from 10 to 50 to 200. The force fell short," said Kumar. 

- Ends

Md Hizbullah

Md Hizbullah is working as a Special Correspondent with India Today TV and Aaj Tak. In his more than a decade long career in investigative journalism, he has done several stories that created political ripples and even caused Suo Moto actions by the Supreme Court of India.

He was the first journalist to travel deep inside illegal rat-hole coal mines in Meghalaya with a camera and brought out the dark reality of the mafia-controlled coal mines in India's northeastern province. Through his deeply-rooted network of sources and investigative skills, he managed to bring the truth behind one of India's most sensational celebrity death mysteries — Sushant Singh Rajput death case. His investigation was the first and only that brought the testimony of AIIMS and Central Forensic Science Laboratory officials involved in the investigation, who categorically rejected the murder theory.

His 2018 investigation into the 2008 bomb blasts outside theatres in Maharashtra was submitted as evidence before the Bombay High Court by the police. The investigation showed startling confessions of two Sadhak's of the Goa-based right-wing organization Sanatan Sanstha who admitted their role in the blasts. These individuals were earlier acquitted by the lower court.

His investigation into the security breach of Prime Minister Narendra Modi during the 2022 assembly elections created a political storm. Testimonies of senior police and intelligence officials showed how PM’s security was compromised despite substantial intel inputs. The story created an unmatched political impact that saw several senior ministers from the union government coming forward and quoting the report. Almost all Chief Ministers of BJP ruled states held separate press conferences based on his story.

His other investigations include exposing the underground network of the illegal cross border immigration networks working along India-Bangladesh borders, exposing the vigilante groups receiving special training to attack people they suspect of transporting bovine cattle for slaughter, mass distribution of cash during India's general elections and underground bomb factories in West Bengal.

READ MORE