Vietnamese crab exporter

Sting operation exposes how Bihar government plays with future of kids. India Today exclusive

Beyond visible symptoms encapsulated in images coming out of the state's creaky examination centres, an investigation by India Today has diagnosed what afflicts Bihar's education system.

Advertisement
Sting operation exposes how Bihar government plays with future of kids. India Today exclusive
India Today investigation

A sail of cheat sheets, mass copying, the undeserving moving out as cream of the crop and real talent suffering a devastating failure - schooling in Bihar has been a subject of international derision for years now.

Beyond visible symptoms encapsulated in images coming out of the state's creaky examination centres, a damning investigation by India Today has diagnosed what afflicts Bihar's education system.

advertisement

The findings point to a paradox of neglect, apathy and chronic corruption on the one side and excessive government pressure and interference on the other.

At Hajipur in Vaishali district, for example, India Today's investigative team met a full-time beautician, who confessed she had been involved in checking Class 12 answer sheets.

Lalita Chaudhry, who runs a boutique and a beauty parlour, is designated as a teacher on official records, she revealed.

TEACHER WHO NEVER TOOK A CLASS

It all started when an acquaintance showed her as staff on paper at a bogus school in Hajipur, Chaudhry told India Today. "He opened the school and gave my name as a teacher," she admitted. "But they don't hold any class. I was never called in to take class."

Still, she was assigned to check answer sheets for the Hindi test. "I would only check up to 50 copies, not more than that," Chaudhry acknowledged.

That was just tip of the iceberg.

DETAILS OF INDIA TODAY INVESTIGATION

As India Today's investigation moved further, more skeletons came tumbling out of Bihar's closet.

At the women's MDDM College in Muzaffarpur, a test-checking centre for this year's intermediate exams, principal Mamta Rani disclosed what was wrong in the system that failed around 64 percent of Class 12 students this year.

"Circumstances under which exam papers were checked themselves are responsible. More than half of our teachers for 10+2 were on a strike to demand equal pay for equal work. They were pressured to call off their strike and deliver the results," she said.

Pressure by the state government to churn out results quickly appeared to be only one factor.

CHECKING ANSWER PAPERS BEYOND CAPACITY

She now explained how the entire staff was forced to examine the key school-leaving papers, beyond capacity.

"Teachers were under so much of pressure to check them quickly. Someone who could see 30 sheets in a day was given 60. This obviously generates mistakes. There was pressure everywhere to speed up work," the principal noted.

Embarrassed after footage of a couple of so-called toppers unable to answer basic questions went viral last year , the Nitish Kumar government ordered tough measures to curb cheating. But the upshot appears to be far from ideal.

advertisement

"Examiners are scared after what happened last year. A sword is hanging over them. If they are generous, the test-papers could be sent for re-checking. That's why they are inclined towards giving less marks and not more," Rani said.

INCOMPETENT TEACHERS

Incompetent teachers also seemed to have played their role in ruining careers.

Dr Narayan Das, Principal of Hajipur's Vaishali Mahila College and an evaluation director himself, admitted that middle-school teachers were given papers for Class 12th to check.

"Many designated teachers were absent. So what happened in between was that middle school teachers were called in because of which a lot of blunders happened," he said. "If someone deserved 10 out of 10, he got zero. We can see it's injustice but can't do anything. Our job is limited to only scrutinise the aggregate."

A physics professor at Muzaffarpur's Dr Jagannath Mishra College, Prem Kumar disclosed the levels of overload he and his colleagues had been burdened under during evaluation. "I believe 80, 90, 100 copies were being cleared when no one is capable of completing more than 50," Kumar claimed.

advertisement

"All this was playing out right in front of your eyes, no?" asked the reporter. "Right there," Kumar replied.

Also read: Every house in this Bihar village has an engineer, 20 clear IIT this year

Also read: All 'Super 30' candidates clear IIT JEE Advanced!

WATCH | Bihar exam scam: Rot in the state's education Nitish Kumar's biggest failure?

Md Hizbullah

Md Hizbullah is working as a Special Correspondent with India Today TV and Aaj Tak. In his more than a decade long career in investigative journalism, he has done several stories that created political ripples and even caused Suo Moto actions by the Supreme Court of India.

He was the first journalist to travel deep inside illegal rat-hole coal mines in Meghalaya with a camera and brought out the dark reality of the mafia-controlled coal mines in India's northeastern province. Through his deeply-rooted network of sources and investigative skills, he managed to bring the truth behind one of India's most sensational celebrity death mysteries — Sushant Singh Rajput death case. His investigation was the first and only that brought the testimony of AIIMS and Central Forensic Science Laboratory officials involved in the investigation, who categorically rejected the murder theory.

His 2018 investigation into the 2008 bomb blasts outside theatres in Maharashtra was submitted as evidence before the Bombay High Court by the police. The investigation showed startling confessions of two Sadhak's of the Goa-based right-wing organization Sanatan Sanstha who admitted their role in the blasts. These individuals were earlier acquitted by the lower court.

His investigation into the security breach of Prime Minister Narendra Modi during the 2022 assembly elections created a political storm. Testimonies of senior police and intelligence officials showed how PM’s security was compromised despite substantial intel inputs. The story created an unmatched political impact that saw several senior ministers from the union government coming forward and quoting the report. Almost all Chief Ministers of BJP ruled states held separate press conferences based on his story.

His other investigations include exposing the underground network of the illegal cross border immigration networks working along India-Bangladesh borders, exposing the vigilante groups receiving special training to attack people they suspect of transporting bovine cattle for slaughter, mass distribution of cash during India's general elections and underground bomb factories in West Bengal.

READ MORE