Supreme Court bars NSA detention based only on police confession, honours clerk
The Supreme Court's judgment combined a ruling on the limits of preventive detention under the NSA with a personal tribute to Deswal, whose research assistance the bench said formed part of the work that led to the ruling.

In a rare gesture, the Supreme Court on Tuesday dedicated a judgment to a law clerk-cum-research associate who had assisted in a case on the detention of an accused under the National Security Act. In the same judgment, the court ruled that a confession made by an accused before a police officer cannot be the basis for detaining him under the NSA.
A bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu expressed grief over the death of Ritwik Deswal, who worked in Justice Datta's office and died four days before his 27th birthday. The judges said the judgment carried the mark of his final work and recorded their appreciation for his research assistance.
"Human life is fragile. Yet, in the ordinary course of living, we seldom pause to recognise just how fleeting it is; and when life finally confronts us with that fragility, the realisation often comes too late. On that note, at the very outset, we begin on an unconventional premise," the bench said.
"One of our dearest law clerks-cum-research associates, Ritwik Deswal, left for his heavenly abode four days short of his 27th birthday, which happens to be today. As we pronounce this judgment, which bears the quiet and indelible imprint of his final labours, we wish to record our deep appreciation for the invaluable research assistance rendered by him in the build-up to the preparation of this judgment," it said.
The top court said Deswal's untimely death had left an "excruciatingly deep void". "Even in his final hours, his thoughts remained firmly anchored in the pursuit of truth and the service of justice. It is, therefore, with profound personal sorrow and grief that we dedicate this final collaboration to his memory, his integrity, his enduring commitment to the law, his love for academia, and his other great qualities of head and heart," the bench said.
On the legal issue, the apex court said preventive detention has always been regarded as an exceptional measure and must be used with the utmost circumspection. It said such power should be invoked only in the rarest of rare cases where the circumstances genuinely warrant it.
