Vietnamese crab exporter

Congress attacks BJP's UCC push after Maharashtra panel member resigns

Congress has accused the Modi government of using the Uniform Civil Code to deepen social divisions after Justice R C Chavan resigned from Maharashtra's UCC panel. The clash has sharpened scrutiny of state-specific UCC laws and the BJP's push to expand them before the 2029 Lok Sabha election.

Advertisement
Rahul Gandhi and Mallikarjun Kharge
Rahul Gandhi and Mallikarjun Kharge

The Congress on Wednesday alleged that the Modi government was using the Uniform Civil Code not as a measure of legal reform but as "an instrument of division, disruption and diversion" and a way to keep society polarised. The party made the charge after former Bombay High Court judge Justice RC Chavan resigned from the Maharashtra government's panel set up to prepare a draft for implementing the UCC in the state.

advertisement

Congress general secretary in-charge communications Jairam Ramesh said the resignation raised wider questions, apart from Justice Chavan's concerns over how the committee was functioning. He said the move also brought into focus the BJP's push for separate UCC laws in different states.

In a statement posted on X, Ramesh said, "A retired High Court judge has shown courage to resign from a committee set up by the Maharashtra government to prepare a uniform civil code for the state. Here is our statement on the non-uniform 'Uniform' Civil Codes (UCC) the HM is trying to bulldoze through in every state." He asked whether the Constituent Assembly had ever imagined a situation in which every state would enact its own version of a UCC, and said, "The answer is a resounding no." He also asked whether the makers of the Constitution led by B R Ambedkar had envisaged states competing with one another to frame different UCCs based on "the political machinations and calculations of one political party" and added, "Again, the answer is a resounding no."

Ramesh said the Modi government had referred the issue of the UCC to the 21st Law Commission of India on June 17, 2016. He said the commission, after extensive research, published its Consultation Paper on Reform of Family Law on August 31, 2018, and concluded that, "The formulation of a Uniform Civil Code is neither necessary nor desirable at this stage". He said the commission instead recommended addressing discrimination within individual family laws while preserving India's legal and cultural diversity. According to Ramesh, the government ignored the findings of the very commission it had asked to examine the issue because they did not suit its political agenda.

He further said that over the last three years, BJP-ruled states had pushed through their own versions of the UCC. He pointed out that the law came into effect in Uttarakhand from January 27, 2025, while the Gujarat Assembly passed the UCC Bill on March 24, 2026, the Assam Assembly on May 27, 2026, and the Madhya Pradesh Assembly on July 21, 2026. Ramesh said these state-level UCCs, which he said were never envisaged in the Constitution, were not uniform. "They contain different provisions, different penalties, different procedures and significant exemptions. Contrary to claims, the Uttarakhand UCC, the only one in force, continues with a number of patriarchal traditions and is creating many problems for perfectly law-abiding residents of the state," he said.

advertisement

Ramesh also referred to Union Home Minister Amit Shah's statement that a UCC would be implemented in all NDA-ruled states before the 2029 Lok Sabha election. He said Shah had made a "typically bombastic announcement" and added that other NDA parties had "lost their voices" and were being silenced by the BJP. "For the Modi Government, the UCC is not an instrument of considered legal reform to be implemented after the widest possible consultations and public debate and with the broadest possible consensus. It is, in reality, an instrument of division, disruption and diversion, a tool for harassment and intimidation, stoking prejudices and keeping society in a state of permanent polarisation," Ramesh said. Later, when asked about the statement, he said, "The UCC bulldozer is to permanently polarise society."

In his letter to panel chairperson Justice Ranjana Desai (retd), Justice Chavan said he had serious reservations about the committee's approach. He criticised the decision to reduce complex social questions, including delayed marriages, "perversions", infertility and rising matrimonial disputes, to binary "Yes/No" options, saying this went against the purpose of building consensus. He said he had initially understood that the committee wanted to gather the views of the people of Maharashtra and build consensus on issues such as late marriages, infertility, unstable marriages and the time taken in dispute resolution. "Now that the misunderstanding is removed, I realise that the aim is to just provide an opportunity to people who may care, to share their responses, in a 'yes or no' format to the questions posed so that analysis of data becomes easy," the letter said.

advertisement

The Maharashtra government had in July set up a seven-member committee headed by retired Supreme Court judge Justice Ranjana Desai to draft a framework for implementing the UCC, which seeks equal laws across religions on issues related to marriage, divorce and property. Justice Chavan resigned from the panel on September 19. The Congress statement also came days after Shah said the BJP-led NDA governments in 21 states would introduce the UCC before 2029, with the next Lok Sabha elections due that year.

The row over the UCC thus sharpened on two fronts, with Justice Chavan questioning the consultation process in Maharashtra and the Congress attacking the BJP's wider plan to bring separate state-level UCCs before the 2029 general election.

- Ends

advertisement