Former Finance Secretary Subhash Chandra Garg and Professor Gaurav Vallabh, a member of the Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister, sparred over India’s latest GDP figures on India Today TV’s Marya Shakil. Garg questioned the scale of revisions in the new GDP series, while Vallabh defended them as a result of changes in economic coverage and methodology.
Garg, who has faced criticism for calculating nominal GDP growth at 2.6% using the earlier estimate of the previous year’s first-quarter GDP, said the key issue was neither the deflator nor the change in the base year, but the revision in the government’s current-price GDP estimate from Rs 86 lakh crore to Rs 80 lakh crore.
“If it brings down from 86 lakh crores to 80 lakh crores... it owes an explanation,” Garg said, arguing that such a large revision warranted scrutiny.
He said the revision amounted to a reduction of around Rs 6 lakh crore and pointed to what he described as an even larger revision in the previous years.
According to Garg, the current-price GDP for 2023-24 was revised upward by around Rs 6-6.5 lakh crore in the latest revision. He argued that such changes were significant enough to warrant a detailed explanation from the government.
“This kind of unprecedented revision I haven't seen in my life at all,” Garg said.
He challenged Vallabh and the government to examine historical data to establish whether current-price GDP had ever been revised by such a large percentage.