Vietnamese crab exporter

AI could lead to human extinction, fear ChatGPT makers; experts stand divided

Experts responded to the warning by tech leaders that the rapidly developing AI technology could pose an existential threat to humanity and said the risk is much more about what we do to each other using AI than what AI can do to us.  

Advertisement
Risk lies in what we do using AI not what it can do to us: Experts respond to tech leaders
Tech leaders issued a warning that artificial intelligence (AI) technology should be viewed as a significant risk to society. (Representational image)

A joint statement issued by the leading brains behind the development of Artificial Intelligence (AI) technology has legitimised an old pop-culture question – will machines take over humanity one day? A noted group of industry leaders have warned that the rapidly developing AI technology could pose an existential threat to humanity and should be considered a societal-scale risk such as pandemics and nuclear wars.

advertisement

Among the 350 signatories of the statement are chief executive of OpenAI (creators of ChatGPT) Sam Altman, chief executive of Google DeepMind Demis Hassabis, and the chief executive of AI safety company Anthropic Dario Amodei. “Mitigating the risk of extinction from AI should be a global priority alongside other societal-scale risks such as pandemics and nuclear war,” the statement said.

ALSO READ | Meta top AI scientist says Elon Musk's fear of AI destroying humanity is completely ridiculous

'STATEMENT LACKS CLARITY'

Independent experts and researchers in the field have cautioned that the recent warning needs to be put in perspective. They are questioning the lack of clarity in the sudden and unusual message. “While certainly well-intentioned, a vague statement like this is not ideal: not a single indication is given about which specific scenario could lead to the extinction of 8 billion individuals,” Prof Nello Cristianini, Professor of Artificial Intelligence at the University of Bath UK, said in a statement.

He further stressed that the burden of clarity lies on the signatories, who should explain the specific path to such an event in case they see it. Other experts also questioned the motive behind the statement and said “it is unusual to see technology leaders in industry calling for greater government regulation of their business activities. We should be alert for some anti-competitive special pleading.”

ALSO READ | Wedding photographer and AI artist imagines Elon Musk as a desi groom. This looks real, says Internet

'RISK LIES IN WHAT WE DO USING AI'

Maria Liakata, a Professor in Natural Language Processing at Queen Mary University of London (QMUL) pointed out that the most severe and immediate risks to humanity from AI are not posed by the possibility that AI might one day autonomously turn against us in the way it often happens in science fiction movies. “The most severe risks come from human shortsightedness” Prof Liakata explained.

Another expert, Dr Oscar Mendez Maldonado, a Lecturer in Robotics and Artificial Intelligence at the University of Surrey, stressed that the risk is much more about what we do to each other using AI than what AI can do to us.  

While some of the experts tend to agree with the concern raised by the group led by giants of AI technology at Silicon Valley, others raise questions about the business motive of the big tech companies behind this alarming note. “The possibility has existed and been recognised since at least Alan Turing's paper in 1950.

advertisement

ALSO READ | How ChatGPT is equipping students for AI-driven education

"It seems inevitable that AI capabilities will be developed further and that AI systems will be used to invent ways to develop AI capabilities further,” Prof Martyn Thomas, Emeritus Professor of IT, Gresham College, said in a response. He further questioned the absence of a "critical point" in current developments in the technology.

“We do not know that there is a limit. Nor could we tell that some critical point had been passed. No one has fully solved the ‘philosophically hard problem’ of consciousness, so there is no definitive way to detect whether an AI system is 'conscious' or 'sentient' and no universal agreement on what these terms even mean,” he added.  

Ethical concerns are also being expressed on the timing of the statement by a section of academic experts calling it a possible unrealistic and a deception from the real risks posed by AI. “I think this is a very dangerous distraction, especially at a time where emerging regulatory frameworks around AI are being developed,” Dr Mhairi Aitken, Ethics Research Fellow, Alan Turing Institute, London warned.

advertisement

ALSO READ | Lawyer faces trouble after using ChatGPT for research, AI tool comes up with fake cases that never existed

“The narrative of super intelligent AI is a familiar plotline from countless Hollywood blockbuster movies, and that familiarity makes it compelling, but it is nonetheless false. AI is all around us today, but these are computer programmes that do what they are programmed to do. Therefore, when we speak about risks from AI, the focus must always be on accountability of people and organisations designing, developing and deploying those systems,” Dr Aitken added.  

“The real threat from AI systems is not a lack of alignment with human preferences, but the inadvertent or malicious abuse of AI systems by incompetent or malicious users”, said Dr Christian Schroeder de Witt, Postdoctoral Research Assistant in Artificial Intelligence, University of Oxford.

ALSO READ | AI will touch every industry and can turn anyone into a programmer, says Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang

Ankit Kumar

Ankit Kumar (a.k.a. Ankiit Koomar) – Editor, Open-Source Investigations, India Today TV & Aaj Tak

Ankit Kumar is the Editor of Open-Source Investigations (OSINT) and Visual Investigations at India Today TV and Aaj Tak.  A two-time JournalismAI fellow with the London School of Economics (LSE), Ankit’s work lies at the intersection of investigative journalism and emerging digital tools as well as use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in journalism. He has pioneered South Asia’s first dedicated OSINT journalism team, bringing cutting-edge technology into the newsroom.

His investigative reports have made national headlines and even been debated in the Indian Parliament. He was the first journalist to uncover the common link between middlemen networks in two of India’s most controversial defence deals—the VVIP AgustaWestland Chopper Deal and the Rafale Jet Deal . His reports have been frequently cited by both the Prime Minister and opposition leaders, shaping public discourse on key national security matters.

Ankit’s deep-dive investigation into the Indian Air Force’s Balakot Airstrikes was the first to feature key eyewitness accounts from the ground. 

Following his report, a UK-based dubious news portal that propagated false claims of large-scale EVM fraud in India was shut down. His stories cover a wide spectrum—from finance, business, and cybersecurity to disinformation, artificial intelligence (AI), and emerging global threats.

His work has been recognized globally, with the Global Investigative Journalism Network (GIJN) listing his reporting among the year’s top investigative stories.

🔹 Connect with him: @AnkiitKoomar on X / LinkedIn
📩 Email: [email protected]

 

READ MORE