Vietnamese crab exporter

Get 37% off on an annual Print +Digital subscription of India Today Magazine

SUBSCRIBE

Bihar | When babus get snared for a tender scam

A squashed sexual assault case opens a can of worms with courts now wanting all officials involved in the scam booked

advertisement
SELECTIVE JUSTICE: Patna High Court. (Photo: Hindustan Times)

The one they call the kingpin may be just a “pawn”. A couple of bishops are taken, one knight has leapt clean off the board. All this is the visible part; the real royalty is perhaps “behind the curtains”, with a probe trying to “save some and implicate a few”. Catch just the small fish, that is. That’s Justice Satyavrat Verma of the Patna High Court, speaking on Bihar’s alleged tender scam. Clearly, his sense of right and wrong is disturbed not just by the alleged racket, but also the insufficiently long arm of the law that was trying to bust it.

advertisement

 

THIS IS A PREMIUM STORY. SUBSCRIBE TO CONTINUE READING

Unlock unlimited access to India Today's premium journalism. Get the stories, insights and analysis that matter.
₹999 / Year
Unlimited Digital Access for one full year across devices.
Cancel anytime
Premium Stories | Award-winning Investigations | Expert Analysis | Exclusive Journalism | In-depth Coverage

The one they call the kingpin may be just a “pawn”. A couple of bishops are taken, one knight has leapt clean off the board. All this is the visible part; the real royalty is perhaps “behind the curtains”, with a probe trying to “save some and implicate a few”. Catch just the small fish, that is. That’s Justice Satyavrat Verma of the Patna High Court, speaking on Bihar’s alleged tender scam. Clearly, his sense of right and wrong is disturbed not just by the alleged racket, but also the insufficiently long arm of the law that was trying to bust it.

 

THIS IS A PREMIUM STORY. SUBSCRIBE TO CONTINUE READING

Unlock unlimited access to India Today's premium journalism. Get the stories, insights and analysis that matter.
₹999 / Year
Unlimited Digital Access for one full year across devices.
Cancel anytime
Premium Stories | Award-winning Investigations | Expert Analysis | Exclusive Journalism | In-depth Coverage

The one they call the kingpin may be just a “pawn”. A couple of bishops are taken, one knight has leapt clean off the board. All this is the visible part; the real royalty is perhaps “behind the curtains”, with a probe trying to “save some and implicate a few”. Catch just the small fish, that is. That’s Justice Satyavrat Verma of the Patna High Court, speaking on Bihar’s alleged tender scam. Clearly, his sense of right and wrong is disturbed not just by the alleged racket, but also the insufficiently long arm of the law that was trying to bust it.

The trail begins with a woman lawyer’s complaint in January 2023 alleging rape in a Pune hotel, in 2017, as well as blackmail and criminal intimidation against IAS officer Sanjeev Hans, then principal secretary, and former RJD MLA Gulab Yadav. Rupaspur police station in Patna registers case No. 18 of 2023. The scrutiny ends up uncovering a massive nexus of corruption, kickbacks and money-laundering centred around rigged public infrastructure and municipal contracts. So, by the time the Patna High Court quashes the rape case against Hans, things have already morphed: into the Enforcement Directorate’s case, ECIR-4, of 2024.

Here, the spotlight eventually settles around Patna-based contractor Rishu Ranjan Sinha (aka ‘Rishu Shree’) and bureaucrats of the state urban development agency, BUIDCO. Rishu’s firm, Reliable Infra Services, comes under the lens with an alleged Rs 20 lakh transfer to the woman—said to be part of the Rs 90 lakh allegedly paid by Hans. Searches in July 2024 yielded a paper/electronic trail. Rishu’s statements led to a vigilance case in September. A February 2025 ED communication prompted the Special Vigilance Unit (SVU) of Bihar Police to register its case No. 5 that April; the ED’s ECIR-13 follows May 22.

The cabal ran a neat operation. The ED’s allegation: babus leaked advance tender information like a sieve, Rishu paid them off, pocketed 8-10 per cent of contract value, got friendly firms to engage his own entities as subcontractors, inflated bills helped dress up the commissions as business expenses. Its span: 35 projects across urban development, water resources, the Kosi barrage, Namami Gange et al. Total worth: Rs 7,482.37 crore. Alleged proceeds of crime: Rs 265.73 crore.

Contractor Rishu Shree, left, and IAS officer Sanjeev Hans

WHO’S BEING SHIELDED?

In judicial custody since May, Rishu had sought anticipatory bail in the ED case. But that’s what turned the scrutiny ‘inward’. On September 11, Justice Verma posed 16 questions, and gave the ED four weeks to answer them. The crux of the issue: the ED had shared information against six top officials. Yet the SVU FIR named only three of those. Why not the others? Why had the ED not even summoned them? Were some being shielded?

The ED’s response was found to be ‘evasive’. Now, the SVU has been asked to explain by November 27. ED questioning had squeezed out the usual juice: alleged gifts, foreign travel, including a Rs 21.92 lakh Austria trip for an officer’s family. It had summoned six officials; two stand suspended. But neither figures in the SVU chargesheet; sources claim it made no move to establish or rule out their involvement. Speculation points to pressure from powerful quarters. As for Hans, he’s absconding—missing from a script that opened with him.

Chief minister Samrat Choudhary holds home and vigilance and general administration: the ED is not his agency; the SVU is. Tolerance, net net, will have to be demonstrated to be zero.

- Ends
advertisement

Explore More